For Exploit type presentations the outline might look like: Background Vulnerability Exploits Impact Mitigation 100/100 Great presentation, I understood a lot about the big picture and indepth in appropriate places. I can explain it both in depth and breadth, and can start to explore. The presenters got me through the difficult pieces, and their submitted work is clear and a great resource. 90/100 Great presentation, but I can't give it 100/100, I am waiting for something better, or have seen something better. Would be 100/100 except... 80/100 Very Good presentation with general sufficient depth and breadth, one of the following issues: a few important points not clear or explained, insufficient depth in an important area With minor feedback and some effort, could be greatly improved. Improvements are more in terms of clarifications and depth in directions taken already. 70/100 I think it is better than 60 but not 80 60/100 Many things presented, but not coherent, I got something significant out of it, but was left with some obvious, important questions unanswered, possibly because the presenters did not understand the material well, possibly because there was no depth to it, possibly because the presenters did not choose to present some key topics. To improve, the presenters have to research, learn, develop additional important topics. 50/100 I think it is better than 40 but not 60 40/100 I got practically nothing out of this, they put in real effort, but I am left understanding little more than a summary of the topic. The presenters lack depth in the area, based on incorrect answers to questions. If I was to start investigating this, I would basically be starting over. This is a serious attempt that failed. My top 10 questions on this subject remain unanswered. To improve, the presenters would need to start over, re-thinking their topic, researching and re creating the presentation. I don't trust their work and can make little use of it when studying for the test. 20/100 I got nothing out of this, and they did not make a real effort to research, summarize and present. 10/100 No one should get this.